Guest Blogger Courtney: 12 Books or Series to Read if You Love Historical Christian Fiction

[Usually blog posts are written by Shirley, Berryville’s library services associate, but today we have a special treat–a guest review written by Courtney, one of our local business owners and fellow book bloggers. She’s guiding us through the world of historical Christian fiction.]

One of my favorite things about reading is learning through story. I believe reading encourages empathy and understanding of humanity with all its flaws and virtues. I also love history. Combine these two, and a reader can learn amazing and lesser-known things about true history and the way people lived in different eras. This is why one of my favorite genres is historical fiction — especially Christian or inspirational fiction because I believe its message of hope and faith to be relevant to life today.

I’m delighted to share a list of historical Christian fiction books that I have read and can highly recommend.


Lori Benton’s The Pathfinders duology

Setting: 1750s-1770s Native American involvement in the American Revolution

Why read it? Beautiful prose-like voice lends depth to an unforgettable saga of redemption.

Mary Connealy’s Trouble in Texas series*

Setting: Post-Civil War Texas

Why read it? Western rom-com at its best! Friendship, ranching, adventure, and general cowboy goings on with womenfolk and outlaws.

*Ebooks also available on Libby.

Jessica Dotta’s Price of Privilege series

Setting: Victorian England

Why read it? Vivid setting, transformative character arc, and a poignant, allegorical story of sacrifice that just might leave you in tears. (This is my absolute favorite historical series.)

Dawn Crandall’s The Everstone Chronicles series

Setting: Gilded Age New England

Why read it? All feature the heroine’s unique first person POV-mystery, heartache, and hope combined in delightful romances and family trials with a few secrets and intriguing settings.

Rachel McMillan’s Herringford and Watts Mysteries series

Setting: 1910s Toronto

Why read it? Humor, friendship, lemon curd, and lady detectives in bowler hats defying social norms and confounding the men in their lives.

Pepper Basham’s Penned in Time series

Setting: 1910s/WWI England and America

Why read it? Character-driven stories of forgiveness and romance against a backdrop of important WWI events.

Single titles:

Jocelyn Green’s The Mark of the King

The Mark of the King

Setting: 1719-22 Early French settlement of New Orleans

Why read it? Amazing and historically accurate story of fortitude and survival with a strong heroine.

Laura Frantz’s The Lacemaker**

The Lacemaker

Setting: Colonial Williamsburg on the cusp of the American Revolution

Why read it? A lady caught between two political sides, a noble rescuer-of-a-hero, themes of belonging and love, familiar patriotic secondary characters, and the Welsh vocabulary.

**Ebook also available on Libby.

 Sarah E. Ladd’s The Headmistress of Rosemere

The Headmistress

Setting: 1816 England

Why read it? Secrets, dreams, Regency propriety, romance, English moors and manors, and a fascinating girls’ school.

Joanne Bischof’s The Lady and the Lionheart

The Lady and the Lionheart

Setting: Circus in 1890s Virginia

Why read it? This emotional and vivid story of redemption, sacrifice, and unconditional love has tiny Beauty and the Beast elements. You will never think of lions or the circus the same!

Tracy Groot’s Maggie Bright

Maggie Bright

Setting: 1940 England and Dunkirk, France during the evacuation event

Why read it? Multiple lead characters offer perspective and heart on both shores during the valiant feat of humanity.

About Courtney:


Full time pizza connoisseur. Part time movie nerd. Blogs about reading and books at The Green Mockingbird. Can be found with tea or coffee and a book in hand at any hour of the day.

[Thanks so much to Courtney for writing this excellent overview of Christian historical fiction! I’m not familiar with this genre, though I love history, and have some great starting points now. 🙂 If you’re interested in any of these books and want to learn more, look them up on our online catalog. We can request any we don’t currently have through ILL.

Do you enjoy Christian historical fiction? What’s your favorite series/author/book in this genre? Have you read these books before? Tell us in the comments!


Author: berryvillelibrary

"Our library, our future"

8 thoughts on “Guest Blogger Courtney: 12 Books or Series to Read if You Love Historical Christian Fiction”

  1. Wonderful post! I’ve read and love many of these books listed, and have a few I need to read! Thank you, Courtney for sharing your love of Christian Historical Fiction!

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: